Conservation Heritage News

Architectural preservationists attacked in Russia

A prominent advocate for historic buildings was pushed off the stage at a public hearing for a new development

A video still shows Elena Tkach getting pushed off stage

Elena Tkach, a Moscow architectural preservationist who also serves in local government, was attacked and allegedly suffered a concussion on 16 October at public hearings over a development project that she opposes. Tkach was there to complain that the developer, a company called InvestStroiKom, had falsified reports.

“The babushki they invited immediately started shouting at me,” she told the local newspaper Moskovsky Komsomolets. “But angriest of all was the developer’s representative (passing himself off as a local resident), who came up from behind me and threw me off the stage.”

A video of the event shows an assailant push Tkach, whose head hits a row of seats, and then fight with her husband. Tkach was knocked unconscious and taken to hospital.

On Sunday 20 October, local residents and activists held a demonstration near the proposed development site in the posh Patriarch’s Ponds neighbourhood, demanding the attacker’s arrest and that a new hearing be held. Some liberal activists, however, have criticised Tkach for her connections to a Russian nationalist organisation that conducts vigilante sweeps against migrant workers and her claims against opposition leaders, who she says are connected to the developer.

Tkach posted to Facebook and her blog yesterday from her hospital bed, to continue the battle to save two historic buildings from being torn down to make way for a sleek new apartment building.

This was the second physical attack on an architectural preservationist in Russia this month. Spasgrad, a heritage group in the city of Nizhny Novgorod on the Volga River, reported that Mikhail Karyakin, a cameraman who documented and supported the organisation’s activities, was beaten on 6 October and hospitalised with head injuries and a broken jaw.

More from The Art Newspaper


5 Nov 13
18:58 CET


It is shameful to attack such a prominent person because what we should know we have to listen to views of others on certain topics than just rushing in pushing someone just like that. We can not keep new things only because old and other designs teach us how others were thinking before us and some other structures have history attached to their existence so in view the attacker must be taken to court of law so that such malpractice or misbehaviour should not be repeated. let us learn to respect the work of others that way the world we are living in will be peaceful. The question might be asked to say was he pushed because he was defending a piece of work that some other old architect produced or there was an attempt to trash anything that is old and that particular person do not want anything that is old. In away if there was no past then we not have the future and if we new things only we would not whether we have developed or not because we have bench mark to measure our successes

Submit a comment

All comments are moderated. If you would like your comment to be approved, please use your real name, not a pseudonym. We ask for your email address in case we wish to contact you - it will not be made public and we do not use it for any other purpose.


Want to write a longer comment to this article? Email


Share this