Art law USA

Collector Ralph Esmerian sentenced to jail

The jeweller, a prominent patron of the Folk Art Museum, will also have to pay $20m in fines

Ralph Esmerian was found guilty of fraud charges. A Endymion Butterfly brooch he sold during his company's bankruptcy proceedings in 2008 was also pledged as collateral to Merrill Lynch

NEW YORK. American Folk Art Museum chairman emeritus and pioneering folk art collector Ralph Esmerian, 71, was sentenced on Friday 22 July to six years in federal prison along with 1,800 days of community service. He was also ordered to pay a $20m fine for bankruptcy, wire fraud and other charges.

According to court papers, Esmerian had double pledged millions in collateral to obtain $210m in loans to purchase and operate the Madison Avenue jeweller Fred Leighton, known for gems once belonging to Marie Antoinette and a Hollywood clientele favoring vintage jewellery.

At the sentencing, US District Court Judge Denise Cote said that Esmerian "lived a life of fraud and deceit on a massive scale".

In the Southern District Court of New York on 15 April, Esmerian had entered a guilty plea forgoing his trial. At the hearing, Judge Cote asked Esmerian, “Did you understand you were violating the law?” and he replied, “I knew it was something wrong.”

The prosecutor David Massey said Esmerian had “embezzled, concealed and converted to [his] own use debtor property worth at least $20m”. Esmerian borrowed $177m from Merrill Lynch Mortgage Capital Inc in 2005 and 2006 and during that time sold pledged collateral valued at $5m and doubled pledged $6m in collateral to obtain a $40m loan from another lender.

In April 2008, his company Fred Leighton filed for bankruptcy protection. He sold his diamond-encrusted 1894 Endymion Butterfly brooch by Boucheron, which he had pledged as collateral to Merrill Lynch, for $2.2m to a dealer on 22 May 2008 and sent $1m in proceeds to his own bank accounts, including one in Switzerland, according to court papers. The prosecutor said this sale was “in violation of bank court orders”.

Esmerian’s attorney Patricia Pileggi at Schiff Harden did not return calls from The Art Newspaper.

Esmerian was a leading collector of folk art and his Fifth Avenue office alone was filled with primitive paintings, weather vanes and quilts. During his tenure as chairman of the American Folk Art Museum, he was instrumental in the museum’s new building, which was sold to the Museum of Modern Art to pay off its debts. On 9 July, the American Folk Art Museum moved back into its old quarters in Lincoln Square.

More from The Art Newspaper


24 Mar 13
17:55 CET


Would like to know what happened to the quilt that was pictured in his home in Architectural digest in Oct 2003, if possible.

Submit a comment

All comments are moderated. If you would like your comment to be approved, please use your real name, not a pseudonym. We ask for your email address in case we wish to contact you - it will not be made public and we do not use it for any other purpose.


Want to write a longer comment to this article? Email


Share this