Museums Conservation Germany

Conservators also oppose plan to sideline Berlin's Old Masters

One of world's greatest collections to be replaced by Modern art

Gemäldegalerie, Berlin

Conservators in Germany have joined the protest over plans to relocate the world-famous collection of Old Masters in Berlin's Gemäldegalerie. Under the Stiftung Preussischer Kulturbesitz's (Prussian Cultural Heritage Foundation) plan, the estimated 3,000 works will move into the much smaller Bode Museum to make way for modern art including the collection of Ulla and Heiner Pietzsch. Any Old Master that cannot be displayed in the smaller space will go into storage for an estimated six years until a new space is found for the collection on the capital's Museum Island.

The move, which was announced at the beginning of July, poses a “significant conservation risk”, said a statement released by the Bonn-based Verband der Restauratoren (Association of Restorers) on 19 July. The association, which has around 2,500 members, argues that the Pietzsch collection should move into the Gemäldegalerie only when a suitable location has been found to accommodate the Old Masters. “Only then can transport be reduced and the possibility that large parts of the collection will disappear into stores for years be avoided,” the statement said. “Any handling, packaging and transportation—even within the building—means mechanical stress and climatic changes to the works, which weakens their substance.”

Around 12,000 people, including Prince Georg Friedrich of Prussia, have signed a petition against emptying the Gemäldegalerie of its Old Masters. The petition was set up by Jeffrey Hamburger, an art historian at Harvard University. Earlier, the Verband Deutscher Kunsthistoriker (Association of German Art Historians) wrote an open letter to Germany's minister of culture, Bernd Neumann, protesting “vehemently” against the plans. But the Bundestag has already made €10m available for the renovation of the Gemäldegalerie, setting the wheels in motion for the move.

The Berlin-based collectors Ulla and Heiner Pietzsch have donated 150 works of art, valued at €120m. But their gift was made on the condition that the works by artists including Magritte, Pollock and Ernst will eventually be on permanent display.

Heiner Pietzsch, an industrialist, has hinted to the German media that should the deal collapse, their heirs would have a lot of art to sell.

More from The Art Newspaper

Comments

7 Sep 12
14:43 CET

JUAN BAUTISTA, CEDR

Please dont do that, i give you a big warehouse to put that modern garbage, let the classical art intact.

10 Aug 12
16:20 CET

CATHY SANTORE, NEW YORK

That the alte meisters should be removed to make way for the neue meisters is a step towards supporting ignorance of European cultural history. It is a tragedy. A place for the modern works should be found elsewhere.

3 Aug 12
15:18 CET

CHARLIE GARNETT, TROO

To follow up my previous comment - if its not the family demanding the removal of the present collection to show their gift & its not the curators - who is ?

3 Aug 12
15:18 CET

CHARLIE GARNETT, TROO

Whilst I fully understand the wishes of the Pietzsch family that their donation should be on view (too many museums hide donations), to force a major museum to store much of its original collection just to gratify their egos, sorry, their terms & conditions in the immediate future is disgusting. Find an old town house or build a new museum & then it can be on permanent view without disrupting anyone & then both collections can be admired equally. If the family don't want to give the buildings, encourage a sponsor to ....

Submit a comment

All comments are moderated. If you would like your comment to be approved, please use your real name, not a pseudonym. We ask for your email address in case we wish to contact you - it will not be made public and we do not use it for any other purpose.

Email*
 
Name*
 
City*
 
Comment*
 

Want to write a longer comment to this article? Email letters@theartnewspaper.com

 

Share this