Shining a light on photography
With several specialist photography dealers present at this year’s fair, the medium’s star is rising in Miami
By Gareth Harris. From Art Basel Miami Beach daily edition
Published online: 05 December 2013
Art Basel Miami Beach is not just a prime commercial platform for major modern and contemporary art galleries from across the world; this year, a handful of specialist photography dealers are presenting work.
Significantly, for the first time, the veteran New York gallery Pace/MacGill will take part in the Florida fair. “We are very excited to participate in Art Basel Miami Beach as we have seen an increasing number of new collectors from around the world join the ranks of museum directors, museum curators and familiar clients who enthusiastically attend the fair,” says a spokeswoman. “Miami is particularly interesting as a unique intersection of the art world,” says a spokeswoman for the Kicken Berlin gallery, which is showing works by Otto Steinert (see box), Harry Callahan and Erwin Blumenfeld.
Crucially, there is an existing group of photography enthusiasts in Miami; the property developer Marty Margulies, who first opened his collection to the public in 1999 at the Warehouse in the Wynwood Arts District, owns more than 2,000 photographs. His curator, Katherine Hinds, says: “We decided to collect photography in the 1990s. The Gurskys were stacked in Mr Margulies’s hallway, and other photographs were piled up under the Rothkos and Lichtensteins, so we decided to open a space [the Warehouse],” she says. “There is no game plan with collecting photography. We buy works if they fit into the rhythm of the collection, and we collect artists in depth.”
“I don’t see photography as photography per se, I see it as art,” says the property developer and Design Miami co-founder, Craig Robins, who collects “unique” photographs by John Baldessari dating from 1970s to today, and early documentary imagery by Paul McCarthy capturing the US artist’s performance work. Meanwhile, the Miami-based collecting couple Don and Mera Rubell own a key piece by Cindy Sherman: Untitled (#397), 2000, along with a series of works by the French artist Jean-Pierre Khazem.
Dina Mitrani, the owner of the eponymous photography gallery in Wynwood, says that apart from a few institutional buyers, notably Bonnie Clearwater during her time as the director of the Museum of Contemporary Art North Miami, her clients are mainly private patrons. She hopes that the highly anticipated Pérez Art Museum Miami, which opened yesterday, will set up its own photography department with an assigned curator. For now, a museum spokeswoman says that its “strong and expanding collection of photography” will be in evidence in the exhibition “Image Search: Photography from the Collection” (to 27 July 2014).
For both public and private organisations, there are opportunities in the market, which is burgeoning but has not yet reached boiling point. Philippe Garner, the international head of 20th-Century decorative art and design at Christie’s, says that the photography market “has remained solid; it has not been pumped up by speculation. The collectors are in for the long game.” Recent auctions have shown that major works by important 20th-century practitioners can still be bought for relatively affordable sums. At the dedicated Phillips sale in London in November, William Eggleston’s Cadillac, 1966-71, a porfolio of 13 chromogenic prints, sold for only £40,000 (est £35,000-£45,000).
According to the research firm ArtTactic, “the greatest proportion of value”, or most money spent, was found in the $10,000-to-$50,000 price range at the dedicated sales held by Christie’s, Sotheby’s and Phillips in Paris and London last May. “At Phillips and at Christie’s, the majority of sold lots and sold value were still in lots below $50,000,” says the ArtTactic auction analysis of June 2013.
The difference between a vintage print, which is generally made within a year of the negative, and an edition, which is made after, should be noted. The scale of the print—with large-format works at a premium—and the size of the edition are also factors that influence value, Garner adds. A discerning collector could acquire a 20th-century modern masterpiece for a fraction of the cost of an equivalent work in painting or sculpture, says the Pace/MacGill spokeswoman. “This situation is, however, changing as the supply of great photographs diminishes,” she adds.
“Generally the market is strong for rare and exceptional icons from most genres; [our] November sale certainly supported that, with works being sold by Gilbert & George and also [Edward] Steichen,” says Lou Proud, head of photographs at Phillips in London. Indeed, brand names or “classic examples by masters of photography”, as ArtTactic describes them, appear to be driving the market; Steichen’s Richard Strauss, New York, 1904, fetched £92,500 at Phillips, (est £80,000-£120,000). “Collectors who started with contemporary works have started to move backwards,” says a spokeswoman for Kicken Berlin.
But a tranche of big names have achieved stratospheric prices at auction, placing them in the blue-chip “trophy” art bracket. For instance, an edition of Sherman’s Untitled #96, 1981, fetched $3.9m (with buyer’s premium) at Christie’s New York in May 2011. “There are the super-expensive contemporary photographic works by a tiny number of practitioners fetching prices that can exceed $1m. The galleries representing these latter artists have carved them a place in the contemporary art market,” Garner says.
This disparity in prices for critically acclaimed artists across the Modern and contemporary canon has left some market specialists bemused. Art adviser Todd Levin, the director of New York-based Levin Art Group, has organised an exhibition of works by US photographer Stephen Shore, “Something + Nothing”, at Sprüth Magers gallery in London (until 11 January 2014), including vintage works from the series “American Surfaces” (1972-73) and “Uncommon Places” (1973-79).
“The current photography market is not a function of quality but an indication of how collectors' tastes, often in a herd mentality, are driving the market,” he says, adding that the most expensive works in the show cost around $30,000. “There is tremendous opportunity for collectors in the Modernist photography market: one could purchase all of the Shore works in the current exhibition for approximately 25% of the price paid for the Sherman [at auction in 2011]”.
A snapshot of photographs at the fair
Otto Steinert, Luminogramm, 1952, gelatin silver bromide print, Kicken Berlin gallery
The German-born photographer and doctor, Otto Steinert, founded the Fotoform group of photographers, which created mainly abstract imagery, in 1949, and organised the first of three exhibitions in 1951 under the title “Subjective Photography”. “[The Subjective Photographers] retained many of the experimental techniques practised at the Bauhaus before the war but worked in a darker, edgier style,” says a description provided by the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York. The auction record for his work, achieved at Sotheby’s Paris in 2011, stands at €41,550 (est €12,000-€15,000); this year, sale prices at auction have been as low as €2,000.
Tina Modotti, Las Piernas, around 1925, gelatin silver print, Howard Greenberg Gallery, New York
Modotti, who was born in Italy in 1896, has been described as a model, muse, silent film actress and Mexican revolutionary. Her romantic entanglement in the 1920s with the photographer Edward Weston sparked her own interest in the medium. She is known for her politically charged images of labourers and city slums, along with still-lifes of hammers and sickles. Surprisingly, her sale prices have remained consistent at auction over the past 20 years: her third highest selling work at auction fetched $189,500 (with buyer’s premium) at Christie’s New York in 1993 (Two Callas, 1925) while the auction record of $363,750 (est $200,000-$300,000) was achieved in April at the same auction house for Untitled (Texture and Shadow), 1924-26.
Irving Penn, Mascara Wars, New York, 2001 (edition of 15), Fuji Crystal Archive Print, Pace/MacGill, New York
The US photography titan Irving Penn (1917-2009) straddled the 20th century, making key portraits, fashion photographs and still-lifes across six decades. His pictures of the Paris couture collections in 1950 “revised the visual aesthetics of fashion photography”, says a Pace/MacGill spokeswoman. Fashion photography is, so to speak, in vogue; an edition of this work sold at Christie’s New York in April for $60,000 (est $30,000-$50,000). A 51-lot, “white glove” sale of Penn’s works at Christie's Paris in November 2011 totalled $2.9m—still much less than the record price paid at auction for a single Cindy Sherman work ($3.9m). Collectors may well be asked to loan their works to museums, which still mount major shows dedicated to Penn; “Irving Penn: Portraits” at the National Portrait Gallery in London in 2010 boosted the photographer’s commercial and critical profile.
Submit a comment
All comments are moderated. If you would like your comment to be approved, please use your real name, not a pseudonym. We ask for your email address in case we wish to contact you - it will not be
made public and we do not use it for any other purpose.
Want to write a longer comment to this article? Email firstname.lastname@example.org