The rise of the art adviser
Professional advice is a growth industry, as more collectors seek help in navigating the art world—and making wise investments
By Melanie Gerlis. From Art Basel daily edition
Published online: 18 June 2014
“I wish there were a qualification for art advisers,” says Arianne Levene, one of hundreds of art advisers in town for Art Basel this week. Dealers have been complaining about the proliferation of art advisers—who act as consultants for collectors—for a while: these intermediaries can block the direct relationships that gallerists would prefer to have with buyers. Now that the advisers themselves are fussing, perhaps the job description is being stretched too thin. “A lot of young girls with gmail accounts can give art advisers a bad name,” says the London-based adviser Emily Tsingou.
In general, art advisers make recommendations to the collectors they represent on works that they should buy, how to manage them and—more often than they like to admit—how they should go about valuing and selling their works. Tsingou compares what she does with being “an architect”, avoiding the accusation that advisers impose their views on their clients. “We are helping someone to develop their taste,” she says.
The role of an art adviser is not new. In her book, Big Bucks: the Explosion of the Art Market in the 21st Century, published this month, Georgina Adam traces it back to the 17th century when the painter Diego Velázquez bought works for King Philip IV of Spain. However, their number has certainly swelled alongside the market over the past decade.
The heavyweight advisers have deep backgrounds in the art world, and enviable connections to the wealthy, and are largely in the US, where the intermediary role has been dominant for longer. For most advisers, the cornerstone of their businesses has been serving one or two major art buyers (and their friends) over a number of years. Among this group is Allan Schwartzman (whose long-term clients include the Dallas philanthropist and collector Howard Rachofsky), Thea Westreich (who counts the venture capitalist Richard Kramlich among her clients) and Sandy Heller (who advises Steve Cohen and Roman Abramovich).
The power that such advisers have in the market was underlined in March when Amy Cappellazzo joined forces with Schwartzman to form Art Agency, Partners, having left her post as the chairman of Christie’s post-war and contemporary art department.
Follow the money
Collectors’ demands have shifted as art buyers, who generally also have day jobs, now have less time to commit to understanding art and the mechanisms of its opaque market. Schwartzman says his role involves bridging the gap between “how the market likes to appear to function and how it [actually] functions”.
Many art advisers today have some sort of grounding in finance and are likely to sympathise when their clients want to know if what they are buying is a decent investment, not least given the seemingly inexorable rise of art prices. “It’s not a case of ‘could I sell it tomorrow?’, but people are understandably worried that they are being taken advantage of,” Levene says.
Advisers’ clients say that it is also about getting access to otherwise hidden works. Mervyn Metcalf, a London investment banker, generally buys direct but, he says: “I often find it helpful to have someone who is professionally linked into the sector who can get an early look at new artists and at works that are being sold privately that I otherwise wouldn’t see.”
The range of services available makes the number of advisers—who range from one-man bands to full-scale businesses—impossible to pin down, and their quality difficult to assess. They now offer to organise exhibitions (commercial and non-commercial), consult for museums and give philanthropic advice; some specialise in working with private collectors, some with corporations or other institutions, and often on all things art-related. Art Agency, Partners’s website says that the firm will, on a selective basis, also “provide strategic counsel to artists, aimed at fulfilling their career goals”, something that might send shivers down the spine of the dealers at Art Basel this week.
Show me the money
Broadly speaking, the way that advisers are paid is either by charging a fee per transaction (generally around 10% of a purchase price) or by charging a regular retainer. The latter, says Tsingou, means that there is no “market incentive” to buy works, so she can instead focus on her clients’ needs.
Other advisers prefer the commission route, which can prove less intimidating to buyers in geographic areas where the art market is more in its infancy. Jehan Chu, a Hong Kong-based adviser, says that his work largely involves introducing buyers from Asia to the market, and providing them with a “collecting thesis”, in full expectation that they will then be able to shop independently. He says: “The more they feel confident to buy on their own, the more I feel I’ve done my job.”
The wheat from the chaff
While Chu, who built his career at Sotheby’s in New York and Hong Kong, has established a good reputation for his business, dealers are frustrated by the modus operandi of other intermediaries, particularly in Asia. “We don’t have any access to mainland China; everything there is done through art advisers. But we insist on knowing where the works are going eventually, which can be difficult,” says Thaddaeus Ropac, of Galerie Thaddaeus Ropac (2.0/B11).
Ropac says that this additional link in the chain is not always to the advantage of the end-buyer. “There are so many people with business cards that say ‘art adviser’ but sometimes they don’t seem to know much.”
Christophe Van de Weghe, of Van de Weghe Fine Art (2.0/D7), says that this problem is not limited to Asia. “A lot of [art advisers] are clueless. If buyers are paying you, then you had better be good. When looking at young, cutting-edge work in particular, 99% of the artists will be gone in 20 years.” In his field—high-end, Modern and contemporary work on the secondary market—most of the emerging advisers are redundant. “If I am selling a work for $5m then I want to have a relationship with the buyer,” he says.
Finding a good adviser is, however, “very difficult”, Tsingou says, and, in the absence of any formal qualifications, a recommendation is the best way forward: “You can’t just go and find one on the internet.”
“Some sort of degree in art history would be a start,” Levene says. It is also important to keep the gallerists onside. Schwartzman advises: “Choose someone who is respected by the art dealers you respect.”
When advisers and their clients fall out…
Once a client finds an adviser, the possible pitfalls of not formalising the relationship is highlighted by a recent legal dispute. In an ongoing case this year, the Iranian-born collector Eskandar Maleki sued Amir Shariat for allegedly taking undisclosed commissions from the sale and purchase of art bought on Maleki’s behalf over nine years. Shariat, who denies the charges, has counterclaimed against Maleki and his wife Fatima for, among other things, harrassment and defamation, accusations that the couple deny. One issue that has emerged is whether Shariat was helping out as a “family friend”, seeking to establish his reputation in the art world, or whether her was offering his professional advice as an “art adviser”. The adviser Emily Tsingou, who did not comment on this particular case, says that while a “gentleman’s agreement is okay, it is best to have the terms of the relationship drafted by a lawyer”.
Art advisers in Basel this week:
Jehan Chu, Vermillion Art Collections: Chu worked at Sotheby’s in New York for six years before the auction house sent him to Hong Kong to expand its business there. Fluent in Mandarin and Cantonese, and a trained auctioneer, he struck out on his own in 2008, founding Vermillion. Most of his clients are based in Hong Kong, but he also works with Singaporean and mainland Chinese private individuals and corporate collectors—generally property groups. Chu is also the vice-chairman of Hong Kong’s Para Site Art Space.
Arianne Levene, New Art World: Levene specialises in contemporary art from the Middle East and Asia, through her London business, which she founded in 2005. She previously worked in UBS’s private banking team, as well as for Jacob Rothschild, the British billionaire banker, on “all things art-related”. Her clients are all finance professionals. Levene organises non-selling shows on behalf of her clients, including “Rashid Rana: Perpétuel Paradoxe”, the first contemporary art exhibition to be held at Paris’s Musée Guimet (2010).
Allan Schwartzman, Art Agency, Partners: With 16 years of art advisory experience at the highest end of the contemporary art market, Schwartzman has earned tastemaker status. His background as a trained art historian and a curator have stood him in good stead (he was founding staff member of New York’s New Museum). The Dallas collector Howard Rachofsky is a long-term client, and he also advises Bernardo Paz, for whom he also works as the creative director and chief curator at the Instituto Inhotim in Brazil.
Emily Tsingou, Emily Tsingou Fine Art: Tsingou worked as an independent curator and art adviser before founding her own contemporary art gallery in London in 1997. After ten years she says that it was a natural progression for her to go back to art advisory as she wanted to focus on just a few clients. She says her work now is “not just walking around an art fair”, citing the more philanthropic work she is doing with the privately funded The Museum Partnership Collection and the UK-based Berrydown Foundation.
Amelie von Wedel, Wedel Art Advisory: Von Wedel trained as an art historian as well as studying business, and founded her advisory company in 2006. Her clients include The Arts Club, in London, managing its collection and a programme of exhibitions, and the Emdash Foundation, where her work ranges from “designing the website to strategic development”. She also advises private clients, particularly from her native Germany, where she says art advisory is a small, but growing, area compared with the US and UK.
Submit a comment
All comments are moderated. If you would like your comment to be approved, please use your real name, not a pseudonym. We ask for your email address in case we wish to contact you - it will not be
made public and we do not use it for any other purpose.
Want to write a longer comment to this article? Email firstname.lastname@example.org