Digital Editions
Newsletters
Subscribe
Digital Editions
Newsletters
Art market
Museums & heritage
Exhibitions
Books
Podcasts
Columns
Technology
Adventures with Van Gogh
Art market
Museums & heritage
Exhibitions
Books
Podcasts
Columns
Technology
Adventures with Van Gogh
Vincent van Gogh
blog

Ten surprises about Van Gogh’s ‘Starry Night’

Vincent and his brother Theo once considered the painting a failure—and it only got its name in the 1920s

Martin Bailey
9 June 2023
Share
Van Gogh’s Starry Night (June 1889)

Credit: Museum of Modern Art, New York

Van Gogh’s Starry Night (June 1889)

Credit: Museum of Modern Art, New York

Adventures with Van Gogh

Adventures with Van Gogh is a weekly blog by Martin Bailey, The Art Newspaper's long-standing correspondent and expert on the Dutch painter. Published on Fridays, stories range from newsy items about this most intriguing artist, to scholarly pieces based on meticulous investigations and discoveries. 

Explore all of Martin’s adventures with Van Gogh here.

© Martin Bailey

The most popular painting in New York’s Metropolitan Museum of Art exhibition on Van Gogh’s Cypresses (until 27 August) is undoubtedly Starry Night. It is on loan from the Museum of Modern Art, where it is normally a major attraction, surrounded by admirers.

An unusually quiet moment at an exclusive preview of Van Gogh’s Cypresses at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York

Credit: The Art Newspaper

Van Gogh completed Starry Night in mid-June 1889, a month after arriving at the asylum on the outskirts of Saint-Rémy-de-Provence. But even with such famous paintings, there is always more to discover—so we present ten surprises.

Moonshine in the “wrong” direction

Detail of Van Gogh’s Starry Night (June 1889)

Credit: Museum of Modern Art, New York

Van Gogh illuminated the left side of the church in the landscape, whereas the main source of light would be expected to come from the crescent moon, on the right. Using artistic licence, he made bright light shine on this night-time scene from the stars. It was a painting from his imagination.

A swirling sky inspired by Hokusai

Details of Katsushika Hokusai’s The Great Wave (about 1831) and Starry Night (June 1889)

Credit for Starry Night: Museum of Modern Art, New York

Vincent was a huge admirer of The Great Wave (about 1831). He wrote to his brother Theo a few months before he painted Starry Night: Hokusai’s "waves are claws, the boat is caught in them, you can feel it”. In the Hokusai print, the wave towers over the volcanic peak of Mount Fuji, whereas in Van Gogh’s painting the swirling mass in the sky hurtles towards the more gentle slopes of Les Alpilles, the hills which lie just behind the asylum where he was then staying. These two compositions in blues share a remarkable dynamism. Van Gogh may well have been loosely inspired by Hokusai’s powerful image.

Six tubes of white paint

A week before starting Starry Night Vincent received fresh art supplies from Theo in Paris, including two large tubes of cobalt blue, one of ultramarine and six of white paint. Although he certainly did not exhaust all these on this particular picture, he used paint with almost profligate abandon, creating the thick impasto surface of his star-filled sky. The parcel with supplies from Theo also included “tobacco and chocolate”.

A weekend’s work

Van Gogh worked incredibly quickly, probably painting Starry Night over the weekend of 15-16 June. He had thought about a “starry” painting for months and would have frequently observed the Milky Way and other stars from his bedroom window, so he was ready when he took up his brushes. It was not painted at night, but in another cell in the monastery-turned-asylum which served as his studio. Once the canvas was on his easel, progress was swift. In a painting of his studio one can see what is probably Starry Night: the larger picture hanging on the right side of the wall.

Van Gogh’s Window in the Studio (September-October 1889)

Credit: Van Gogh Museum, Amsterdam (Vincent van Gogh Foundation)

The drawing you have probably never seen

Van Gogh’s drawing of Starry Night (June 1889)

Credit: Bremen Kunsthalle (but now held in Moscow)

Van Gogh made drawn copies of ten or so paintings in the summer of 1889, including Starry Night. This drawing was donated to the Kunsthalle Bremen in 1918, but was lost during the chaos of the Second World War. It was looted at a German castle, where it had been sent for safekeeping, by a Red Army officer who took it back to the Soviet Union on a tractor. Back in 1992 I was the first outsider to see the drawing, which was then in the secret storeroom of the State Hermitage Museum in St Petersburg. The Russian government refused to restitute the looted Van Gogh and it was transferred to a ministry of culture store in Moscow, where it languishes.

Was Starry Night a failure?

Vincent had ambivalent feelings about the painting, initially referring to it as a “study”, although a few weeks later it hung in his studio. Realising that Starry Night marked something of a departure from his recent work, Vincent warned Theo that the composition might appear an “exaggeration”— not a realistic landscape. When Theo received it in Paris he responded with a few carefully chosen words of mild criticism, commenting that “the search for style takes away the real sentiment of things”. In November 1889 Vincent wrote to his artist friend Emile Bernard that the painting represented a “setback”, adding that “once again I’m allowing myself to do stars too big”.

The first Van Gogh-inspired novel

First instalment of Octave Mirbeau’s Dans le Ciel (In the Sky), L’Echo de Paris, 20 September 1892

Octave Mirbeau, a writer and critic, saw Starry Night in 1891, a year after Van Gogh’s suicide, writing about the Dutchman’s “admirable madness of skies where drunken stars spin and totter, spreading and stretching into scruffy comets’ tails”. His 1892 novel Dans le Ciel (In the Sky), published in L’Echo de Paris, centres around a tragic artist who paints trees with “their branches twisted” and landscapes “under whirling stars”. It ends with a horrific scene in which the artist saws off his right hand with a hacksaw and then dies. The novel’s main theme is the link between genius and insanity.

Hung in a conservatory

A Rotterdam woman, Georgette van Stolk, bought Starry Night in 1907, coming from Theo’s widow Jo Bonger. Van Stolk kept the painting in her conservatory, but fortunately it appears to have escaped damage from sunlight or damp. After some years she hung a protective curtain in front of it on hot summer days.

MoMA got Starry Night in a swop

Announcement in Bulletin of the Museum of Modern Art, November 1941

Credit: Museum of Modern Art, New York

In 1941 Starry Night was acquired by the Museum of Modern Art. It is often assumed that it was bought, but it was actually an exchange. Starry Night was swapped by the dealer Paul Rosenberg for three paintings bequeathed by Lillie Bliss: Cézanne’s Portrait of Victor Chocquet in an Armchair (now Columbus Museum of Art), his Fruit and Wine (Pola Museum of Art, Kanagawa) and Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec’s May Belfort in Pink (Cleveland Museum of Art). In return Rosenberg offered Starry Night, which he had bought from Stolk, and it became the first Van Gogh to be acquired by a New York museum.

Van Gogh never called it "Starry Night"

Vincent himself never actually referred to the painting as “starry night”, variously giving it the less evocative descriptions of “starry sky”, “night study” and “night effect”. Theo called it “the village in the moonlight”, perhaps regarding it more as a landscape than a depiction of the heavens. After the artist’s death it was often known as “The Stars”. It was not until it appeared in an exhibition in Rotterdam in 1927 that the picture was given the more lyrical title “Starry Night (Sterrennacht in Dutch)".

Other Van Gogh news:

Taschen’s latest mega-tome, The History of Press Graphics 1819-1921 by Alexander Roob, includes a 60-page section on “Van Gogh’s ‘Bible for Artists’”. This reproduces images he admired from journals such as The Illustrated London News, The Graphic and Harper’s Weekly. These illustrations played a key role in inspiring the development of Van Gogh’s own work in the early years when he set out on his career. He regarded his collection of prints as “a kind of Bible for an artist”.

All Adventures with Van Gogh blogposts are © Martin Bailey

Martin Bailey is a leading Van Gogh specialist and special correspondent for The Art Newspaper. He has curated exhibitions at the Barbican Art Gallery, Compton Verney/National Gallery of Scotland and Tate Britain.

Martin Bailey’s recent Van Gogh books

Martin has written a number of bestselling books on Van Gogh’s years in France: The Sunflowers Are Mine: The Story of Van Gogh's Masterpiece (Frances Lincoln 2013, UK and US), Studio of the South: Van Gogh in Provence (Frances Lincoln 2016, UK and US), Starry Night: Van Gogh at the Asylum (White Lion Publishing 2018, UK and US) and Van Gogh’s Finale: Auvers and the Artist’s Rise to Fame (Frances Lincoln 2021, UK and US). The Sunflowers are Mine (2024, UK and US) and Van Gogh’s Finale (2024, UK and US) are also now available in a more compact paperback format.

His other recent books include Living with Vincent van Gogh: The Homes & Landscapes that shaped the Artist (White Lion Publishing 2019, UK and US), which provides an overview of the artist’s life. The Illustrated Provence Letters of Van Gogh has been reissued (Batsford 2021, UK and US). My Friend Van Gogh/Emile Bernard provides the first English translation of Bernard’s writings on Van Gogh (David Zwirner Books 2023, UKand US).

To contact Martin Bailey, please email vangogh@theartnewspaper.com

Please note that he does not undertake authentications.

Explore all of Martin’s adventures with Van Gogh here

Vincent van GoghArt historyPost-Impressionism
Share
Subscribe to The Art Newspaper’s digital newsletter for your daily digest of essential news, views and analysis from the international art world delivered directly to your inbox.
Newsletter sign-up
Information
About
Contact
Cookie policy
Data protection
Privacy policy
Frequently Asked Questions
Subscription T&Cs
Terms and conditions
Advertise
Sister Papers
Sponsorship policy
Follow us
Instagram
Bluesky
LinkedIn
Facebook
TikTok
YouTube
© The Art Newspaper

Related content

Adventures with Van Goghblog
14 May 2021

Irises: anniversary of Van Gogh’s finest garden picture, painted on his first morning in the asylum

Monet asked how the artist who made this exuberant masterpiece could possibly be unhappy—and a century later it became the most expensive work at auction

Martin Bailey
Adventures with Van Goghblog
28 September 2018

How Van Gogh's Starry Night was inspired by Hokusai’s Great Wave

A great admirer of Japanese prints, the whorls of brushstrokes in Vincent's night sky could have been partly suggested by a turbulent sea

a blog by Martin Bailey
Adventures with Van Goghblog
1 March 2024

Ten reasons why we love Van Gogh

It’s not only the art, but also his extraordinary life story

Martin Bailey