The Fine Art Society closes Mayfair gallery after 142 years with 'emotional' sale at Sotheby’s

Sculpture of Peter Pan and painting by Gluck were among the stars of five-hour long auction

Gluck’s Flora’s Cloak (around 1923) sold for £100,000 (est £80,000-£120,000) Courtesy of Sotheby's

The sale at Sotheby’s London yesterday (5 February) of items consigned by the longstanding commercial gallery, The Fine Art Society (FAS), was tinged with nostalgia—even sadness. Early 2018, after 142 years, the FAS gave up its distinctive five-storey premises on New Bond Street in Mayfair, just across the road from the auction house.

The gallery championed artists such as John Singer Sargent and James McNeill Whistler, staging key shows such as the Leigh Bowery Memorial Exhibition co-organised by Lucian Freud in 1995 and Hokusai’s Drawings and Engravings in 1890.

Rising rents, which have been largely attributed to an influx of international fashion houses, led to the relocation of the street’s stalwart art and antique dealerships including Colnaghi. The Fine Art Society subsequently relocated to Chelsea where it runs an office space; it also has a gallery in Edinburgh. “We are looking at doing private sales and re-evaluating our core strengths. We want to keep the core bits, focusing on good British art and design,” says Annamarie Phelps, chair of The Fine Art Society.

The vast Sotheby’s sale included 312 lots—ranging from 17th-century furniture to Victorian sculpture and contemporary painting—with 77.2% sold by lot and 86.1% by value. The top lot, a bronze sculptural model of Peter Pan by Sir George James Frampton (cast in 1987), sold for £346,000 (with buyer’s premium; est £80,000-£120,000).

Other lots in the over £100,000 category included Ivon Hitchens’s painting Trees and Bushes (1952) which exceeded its high estimate (£50,000-£80,000) to fetch £112,500 (with buyer’s premium). Flora’s Cloak (around 1923) by Gluck, the queer artist whose market has picked up in recent years, sold for £100,000 (est £80,000-£120,000). The work, which was owned by Gluck’s lover Constance Spry, is thought to be the artist’s only nude. A source close to the sale says that the work was purchased on behalf of a UK museum.

Phelps says that the sale “was well attended. At the start, there was a full house and it was quite emotional. There were some very interesting responses to a wide range of objects. The [lower] estimates were designed to pull people in.”

The artist Peter Blake, whose digital print of the Fine Art Society Flag (2013) sold for £1,063 (with buyer’s premium; est £700-£1,000), was in attendance along with the London-based dealer Rupert Maas. Asked if he had bought or bid, Maas says that “the prices are low but I had a sense of restraint”, adding that FAS’s departure “leaves New Bond Street looking like a toothless, painted whore”.