Digital Editions
Newsletters
Subscribe
Digital Editions
Newsletters
Art market
Museums & heritage
Exhibitions
Books
Podcasts
Columns
Technology
Adventures with Van Gogh
Art market
Museums & heritage
Exhibitions
Books
Podcasts
Columns
Technology
Adventures with Van Gogh
Fakes & copies
news

Backlash over claim that Egyptian geese were cooked up in 1800s

Museum director and former antiquities minister refute Italian archaeologist’s theory

Hannah McGivern
30 April 2015
Share

An Italian Egyptologist’s claim that the 4,500-year-old Meidum Geese painting in the Egyptian Museum in Cairo could be a 19th-century forgery painted by one of the museum’s curators has drawn ire from archaeologists, including Egypt’s former antiquities minister Zahi Hawass, and has prompted Mahmoud Alhalwagi, the museum’s director, to authorise scientific tests to prove the age of the wall fragment.

Francesco Tiradritti wrote in the April edition of our sister publication Il Giornale dell’Arte that he had identified “anomalies”, including the species of geese depicted (bean and red-breasted, which breed and migrate only in Europe and central Asia), that put the  work’s status as an early masterpiece in “serious doubt”. Tiradritti suggested that Luigi Vassalli, who trained as a painter at the Accademia di Brera in Milan and was supposedly responsible for removing the fragment from the tomb of Nefermaat and his wife Itet (also Atet) at Meidum in 1871, might have created the piece. He recommended scientific analysis to determine whether Vassalli “repainted or completed a pre-existing subject… as he himself had done for other works in Cairo, or if he created an entirely new work”.

Alhalwagi responded by telling Ahram Weekly: “We cannot prove that the painting is a forgery unless state-of-the-art scientific study is used, and this was totally absent from Tiradritti’s research.” He added that tests will be carried out to respond to these “lies”.   

Hawass dismissed the new theory on his website, posting excerpts of correspondence with other archaeologists showing that these species of geese have been found in Egypt. Hawass also wrote that Tiradritti “is an archaeologist and not an art historian, and therefore what he says about art should be questioned”, and that the head of the museum at the time, Auguste Mariette, would never have allowed a fake to enter the institution. “One of these days, someone will say that the Great Pyramid of Khufu itself is a fake,” he wrote.

Fakes & copiesAuthenticationConservation
Share
Subscribe to The Art Newspaper’s digital newsletter for your daily digest of essential news, views and analysis from the international art world delivered directly to your inbox.
Newsletter sign-up
Information
About
Contact
Cookie policy
Data protection
Privacy policy
Frequently Asked Questions
Subscription T&Cs
Terms and conditions
Advertise
Sister Papers
Sponsorship policy
Follow us
Instagram
Bluesky
LinkedIn
Facebook
TikTok
YouTube
© The Art Newspaper

Related content

Restitutionarchive
1 March 2006

Mask on display at St Louis Art Museum "belongs to Egypt”

Zahi Hawass, head of Egypt’s Supreme Council of Antiquities, is asking the museum to return an antiquity he says was looted from Saqqara

Jason Edward Kaufman
Museumsnews
1 April 2015

Masterpiece of ancient Egyptian art could be a modern forgery

The “Meidum Geese” in Cairo’s Egyptian Museum may have been painted by a 19th-century curator

Hannah McGivern
Art Dubai 2018news
20 March 2018

Race to write Modern art history in the Middle East

Market for 20th-century works from the region will benefit from new technologies and deeper scholarship

Anna Brady