Digital Editions
Newsletters
Subscribe
Digital Editions
Newsletters
Art market
Museums & heritage
Exhibitions
Books
Podcasts
Columns
Technology
Adventures with Van Gogh
Art market
Museums & heritage
Exhibitions
Books
Podcasts
Columns
Technology
Adventures with Van Gogh
Art law
news

Deal reached in dispute over Van Gogh painting held at Detroit Institute of Arts

While the parties have reached an agreement, the museum says it spent $100,000 on its defence and that the injunction against it sets a dangerous precedent

Benjamin Sutton
27 March 2023
Share
Vincent Van Gogh, The Novel Reader (Liseuse de romans), November 1888 Via Wikimedia Commons

Vincent Van Gogh, The Novel Reader (Liseuse de romans), November 1888 Via Wikimedia Commons

The dispute over Vincent van Gogh’s Liseuse de romans (The Novel Reader, 1888) has been resolved out of court by the parties who had been claiming rightful ownership of the work. The loser in the case may be the Detroit Institute of Arts (DIA), which an appeals court ordered in January to hold onto the painting pending the resolution of the ownership dispute—it had been loaned to the museum for its blockbuster Van Gogh in America exhibition, which closed on 22 January.

A spokesperson for the museum told the Associated Press that it had spent upwards of $100,000 on its legal defence in the case. It is also petitioning the appeals court to deem its late January injunction “null and void” so that it cannot be cited as a precedent in future disputes. The federal Immunity from Judicial Seizure Statute, which governs international art loans to US museums, stipulates that “no court of the United States [...] may issue or enforce any judicial process” to impact the “custody or control” of an artwork loaned to a US museum. The statute is seen as crucial to securing loans of works that might be the subject of legal disputes or restitution claims.

Brokerarte Capital Partners, the Miami-based art brokerage of Brazilian collector Gustavo Soter, had purchased The Novel Reader in 2017 for $3.7m from Torrealba Holdings, a company owned by Brazilian thoroughbred horse collector Goncalo Borges Torrealba. Brokerarte then loaned the painting to an unnamed third party, who “absconded” with it, as Soter’s original complaint stated. He had lost track of the painting until it was put on public display at the DIA in Van Gogh in America last autumn, leading to his lawsuit in January. The work’s wall label only identified the lender as a private collection in São Paulo.

“Consistent with the confidential settlement, Brokerarte no longer seeks injunctive relief, and therefore, this appeal is moot,” lawyers for Soter wrote in a court filing on 13 March.

The identity of the mysterious absconding party, and the ultimate fate of The Novel Reader, are unknown. Lawyers for Soter have not responded to a request for comment.

Art lawVincent van GoghDetroit Institute of ArtsLawsuits
Share
Subscribe to The Art Newspaper’s digital newsletter for your daily digest of essential news, views and analysis from the international art world delivered directly to your inbox.
Newsletter sign-up
Information
About
Contact
Cookie policy
Data protection
Privacy policy
Frequently Asked Questions
Subscription T&Cs
Terms and conditions
Advertise
Sister Papers
Sponsorship policy
Follow us
Instagram
Bluesky
LinkedIn
Facebook
TikTok
YouTube
© The Art Newspaper

Related content

Art lawnews
19 January 2023

In dispute over Van Gogh painting, Detroit Institute of Arts is ‘blameless’, judge says

A Brazilian collector had sought to bar the museum from returning the artwork after its blockbuster Van Gogh exhibition closes

Claire Voon
Adventures with Van Goghblog
13 January 2023

Van Gogh's Tokyo Sunflowers: Was it a Nazi forced sale? And is the painting now worth $250m?

Bought for a Japanese museum in 1987, the masterpiece has just been claimed by the heirs of a Jewish Berlin banker

Martin Bailey
Lawsuitsnews
27 January 2023

Detroit Institute of Arts ordered to keep Van Gogh painting as lawsuit over its ownership heads to appeals court

A judge had previously dismissed the lawsuit brought against the Michigan museum in a dispute over the canvas “The Novel Reader”

Benjamin Sutton
Art marketnews
23 September 2024

Curator Virginia Brilliant settles her lawsuit against Robilant + Voena gallery and its co-founders

Brilliant, who had sought at least $3m for claims related to her consulting work for the gallery, has withdrawn her complaint as part of the agreement

Tim Schneider