News
China

Antique ivory not affected by China's complete trading ban

Regulation follows partial ban and intensive public campaign

China is closing down ivory carving workshops, factories and shops Plavevski

Mainland China’s complete ban on ivory trading came into effect on 31 December 2017. It follows the government’s previous one-year ban on carved ivory imports announced in February 2015 that was then made permanent. On 30 December 2016 President Xi Jinping declared that China would eliminate the domestic ivory trade within one year. The government incrementally shut down carving workshops and trading platforms throughout 2017, with 67 factories and shops closed by March and another 105 by the year’s end, according to the state news agency Xinhua.

“It is too early to see the number of confiscations or fines issued since the implementation of the ban. And honestly, it still might take a little time to fully shut down all open sales,” says Steve Blake, the chief representative for China of WildAid, which has maintained a publicity campaign against ivory in China, led by the basketball star Yao Ming, since 2012. “But licensed carvers and retail stores started being closed down in March 2017, and were completely closed by 31 December. The next step is to continue cracking down on black-market ivory sales, which are mostly online.”

Blake adds that the art world, including museums and private collectors of ivory antiquities, will not be affected. “Holdings of antique ivory are not affected by the ban. Only the sale and purchase of ivory as a commercial item are banned,” he says.

Prior to the ban, an enthusiasm for ivory fuelled by China’s growing affluence was a major reason why the poaching of African elephants had reached epidemic levels. A 2008 study found that 3.5 tonnes of ivory were consumed legally in China per year, the researcher Daniel Stiles wrote in the Guardian newspaper in 2016. A study of ivory demand, led by Stiles in 2015, found that around 200 tonnes of illegal ivory were smuggled annually into mainland China and Hong Kong between 2009 and 2014, of which only ten tonnes a year were processed and the remainder stockpiled by speculators. During that period, 75% of ivory sales by weight and 90% by volume in China were illegal.

Activists maintained that the remaining legal trade provided cover for the black market, and after several years of countering that ivory was part of China’s intangible craft tradition, the Chinese government agreed. Last year’s partial ban led to an 80% decline in seizures of ivory entering the country illegally plus a 65% decline in raw ivory prices, Xinhua reported at the end of 2017.

“There is strong political support for the ban in China,” Blake says. “It came from the very top when Xi Jinping announced in 2015 that China would soon close its domestic legal ivory market. Now that the ban has been implemented, WildAid is working directly with the government to inform the public that ivory is illegal.”

That political support stems from broad popular opinion: the World Wildlife Fund and the trade monitoring network Traffic found in December 2017 that, while only 19% of Chinese surveyed were aware of the ban, once informed of it, 86% expressed support.

The campaign to ban ivory in China began in 2012 when a documentary made by Yao and WildAid aired on television. In 2013 Yao, WildAid, the African Wildlife Foundation and Save the Elephants launched a public awareness campaign using more than $180m worth of donated media space to built opposition to the trade in China. Yao was joined by Chinese celebrities plus international figures such as David Beckham, Prince William, Richard Branson and the cast of TV show The Walking Dead. Yao also proposed a ban to the National People’s Congress in 2014.

Along with enforcing the ban domestically, mainland China is now taking a lead diplomatically in pressuring other East Asian nations to follow suit, particularly Japan, which continues to have a domestic legal market. Blake says: “China has shown courage and responsibility by banning ivory, and we hope other nations with ivory markets can follow China’s lead.”

Appeared in The Art Newspaper, 298 February 2018